# Donor Stewardship: What Top-Retaining Organizations Do Between Gifts

Stewardship is the set of things an organization does for donors between asks, and it shows up in two numbers: gifts per donor and retention.

## Key takeaways
- Donor stewardship means the work an organization does for a donor between one ask and the next: thanking, reporting what the gift did, and keeping the donor connected to the work.
- In the Virtuous 2026 benchmark report, released in April 2026 and covering 771 mid-sized and large US nonprofits, top-quartile organizations retained nearly 7 in 10 donors, against 54.73% retention across the sample.
- The same report measured 4.15 gifts per donor per year on average and 6.62 among its top performers, so stewardship can be read in how often donors give, not only in whether they return.
- In Bloomerang's 2026 survey of more than 1,000 US donors, 94% said they are motivated to give when an organization tells them exactly where their money will go.
- The form of a thank-you is not the measure: in two preregistered field experiments with 10,000 people, run in 2023 and published in 2025, handwritten thank-you postcards did not raise giving above printed ones (Adena, Huck and Neyse).

Donor stewardship is the work an organization does for a donor between one ask and the next: thanking the donor, reporting what the gift accomplished, and keeping the donor connected to the work. It is measurable, and the organizations that do it well show it in two numbers. In the [Virtuous 2026 Nonprofit Fundraising Benchmark Report](https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/virtuous-releases-2026-nonprofit-fundraising-benchmark-report-median-gift-up-20-as-donors-who-stay-give-more-often-and-more-generously-302748571.html), released in April 2026 and covering 771 mid-sized and large US nonprofits, top-quartile organizations retained nearly 7 out of 10 donors, against 54.73% retention across the whole sample. Donors in the sample gave 4.15 times a year on average, and donors at the organizations the report calls top performers gave 6.62 times.

## What is donor stewardship, in plain terms?

A donor's relationship with an organization has two kinds of moments. The ask is the moment the organization requests a gift. Everything else, from the receipt to the next appeal, is the space between asks. Donor stewardship is what the organization does in that space. The word comes from the idea of a steward, a person trusted to manage something on another person's behalf, and the donor's gift is the thing being managed.

Stewardship is often described as a tone: warm, grateful, donor-centered. A tone is hard to check. A more useful definition treats stewardship as a set of behaviors that should move two measures. The first is retention, the share of last year's donors who give again this year. The second is gift frequency, the number of gifts each donor makes in a year. If an organization's stewardship is working, more donors come back and the donors who come back give more often. Our guide to [why donors stop giving](https://donorinsights.com/articles/why-donors-stop-giving) covers the reasons donors leave. This piece covers what the organization does while they stay.

## How large is the gap between top-retaining organizations and the rest?

In the Virtuous sample, the gap between the top quarter of organizations and the sample as a whole was about 15 points of retention: nearly 70% of donors retained at top-quartile organizations, against 54.73% across all 771. Across the sample, [Virtuous reported](https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/virtuous-releases-2026-nonprofit-fundraising-benchmark-report-median-gift-up-20-as-donors-who-stay-give-more-often-and-more-generously-302748571.html) that the median gift rose approximately 20%, which it attributed to "growth across the broad middle of the donor base", and that donor lifetime value, the total a donor gives over the whole relationship, grew nearly 18%. Gabe Cooper, the company's chief executive, summarized the pattern in the release.

> [T]he donors who do stick around are giving more, giving more consistently, and are more engaged than we've seen in years. — Gabe Cooper, CEO of Virtuous, in the 2026 Nonprofit Fundraising Benchmark Report release

## What does the report say top-retaining organizations do between gifts?

The release describes their approach in one passage rather than a list. Cooper said: "The organizations winning right now aren't trying to grow by adding more names to a list. They're going deeper with the donors they have. Actually listening, building real relationships, staying personal. Not more transactions. More trust." In plain terms, the top organizations he describes spend their effort on the donors already on file, not on acquiring new ones. The release does not publish a checklist of specific practices, and it does not show that any one practice caused the retention gap. The concrete behaviors later in this article come from what donors say they want and from field experiments, and each is paired with a measure so an organization can test it on its own donors.

**6.62 vs 4.15** — gifts per donor per year at the top performers in the Virtuous 2026 benchmark report, against the average across 771 mid-sized and large nonprofits (April 2026 release) ([Virtuous, 2026 Nonprofit Fundraising Benchmark Report](https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/virtuous-releases-2026-nonprofit-fundraising-benchmark-report-median-gift-up-20-as-donors-who-stay-give-more-often-and-more-generously-302748571.html))

> **How to read these benchmarks**
>
> The Virtuous figures come from a software vendor's benchmark dataset, and the sample is mid-sized and large organizations. The release does not state which year's giving the figures cover. For comparison, the [Fundraising Effectiveness Project's Q4 2025 report](https://publications.fepreports.org/archive/2025-q4/), a broader panel of 15,102 organizations not limited to mid-sized and large ones, put overall retention at 43.3%. The two numbers measure different populations, so neither is wrong. The release also does not say whether the top performers on gift frequency are the same organizations as the top quartile on retention, so this article treats them as two separate findings. The sample grew from 571 to 771 organizations in a year, which means year-over-year changes are partly a change in who was counted.

## What do donors say they want between gifts?

Donors are specific about it. In [Bloomerang's 2026 donor survey](https://bloomerang.com/news/bloomerang-releases-2026-giving-signals-report), run with The Harris Poll among more than 1,000 active US donors and 400 fundraising leaders in March 2026, 94% of donors said they are motivated to give when an organization tells them exactly where their money will go. In the same survey, 69% named transparency in financial and program reporting as the top sign they use to judge whether a nonprofit is effective, and 69% named email as the channel they prefer to hear through. These are stated preferences, which often run ahead of behavior, but they point to the same content: a specific account of where each gift's money goes, sent where the donor reads.

Donors who leave say something similar from the other side. Among lapsed recurring donors surveyed for [Neon One's 2026 Recurring Donor Report](https://neonone.com/resources/blog/fundraising-tools-automated-reminders-recurring-donors/), 27% said they stopped because they no longer felt connected to the organization's work or mission. The most common reason donors gave in the survey, at 44.1%, was that they could no longer afford to give, which no stewardship program can fix. A lost sense of connection is the reason an organization can act on, because the organization controls how often a donor hears what the work is accomplishing.

## What is donor stewardship not?

Stewardship is not a matter of stationery. In two preregistered field experiments with a German opera house, covering 10,000 people, with letters mailed in May 2023, [Adena, Huck and Neyse (2025, Experimental Economics)](https://doi.org/10.1017/eec.2025.10033) tested two common gratitude tactics. Adding a "thank you in advance" line to 8,800 appeal letters did not significantly change the response rate (1.6% without the line, 1.8% with it). Sending 1,132 past donors a handwritten thank-you postcard instead of a printed one did not significantly change giving either (18.7% responded after a printed card, 19.3% after a handwritten one). The authors concluded that neither tactic mattered for the success of the campaign.

An older and larger study found the same for thank-you phone calls. [Samek and Longfield (2023, American Economic Journal: Applied Economics)](https://www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/app.20210068) randomized 500,000 new donors at public television stations and a national nonprofit to receive a thank-you call or not. Fundraising professionals had predicted the calls would raise retention by 80%, and the study found a precisely estimated null effect on retention. That study is older than this site's usual data window, so treat it as background, but it points the same way: the channel or format of thanks, on its own, did not change whether donors came back.

The study does not say gratitude is useless. It says the format of the thanks, handwriting versus print, was not what moved donors in that setting. The content that donors say they want, a specific account of where the money goes, is a different thing from the medium it arrives in. An organization with limited staff hours should spend them on what the thank-you and the report say before it spends them on how the envelope looks.

## What does donor stewardship look like as a program?

Each behavior below is paired with the measure it should move, so an organization can tell after a year whether the behavior earned its place on the calendar.

1. Thank every gift promptly, and say what the gift will do in one specific sentence. Measure: the share of first-time donors who make a second gift, which [Virtuous put at 25.84%](https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/virtuous-releases-2026-nonprofit-fundraising-benchmark-report-median-gift-up-20-as-donors-who-stay-give-more-often-and-more-generously-302748571.html) across its sample.
2. Send a report on what the gift accomplished before the next ask, not inside it. Bloomerang's respondents said knowing exactly where their money will go motivates them, and a report on results shows the money went where the organization said it would. Measure: retention of donors who received the report against those who did not.
3. Use email as the default channel for reports, since 69% of Bloomerang's donors named it as their preferred channel. Measure: open and click rates on reports compared with appeals.
4. Publish plain financial and program numbers once a year, since 69% of Bloomerang's donors named that kind of transparency as their top sign of an effective nonprofit. Measure: the renewal rate, the share of last year's donors who give again, in the year after the numbers go out.
5. Watch for donors whose connection is fading, such as a monthly donor who stops opening email, and send news rather than an appeal. Measure: the renewal rate of those flagged donors, against flagged donors from the year before who received no news.
6. Track gifts per donor and retention by the year each donor joined, so improvements show up in the cohort that received the new stewardship. Our guide to [donor cohort analysis](https://donorinsights.com/articles/donor-cohort-analysis) shows how to set that up.

## What would closing part of the gap mean on one donor file?

Picture a fictional organization, Cedar Bend Food Pantry, with 1,000 donors last year. The table below applies the two Virtuous retention figures to that file to show the size of the difference in donors. It is illustrative arithmetic on published rates, not a forecast, and a small organization's starting point may sit closer to the FEP's 43.3% than to the Virtuous average.

Illustrative: donors retained from a 1,000-donor file at two published retention rates (fictional organization, rates from the Virtuous 2026 report, April 2026 release)

| Retention rate applied | Donors giving again | Donors lost |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Sample-wide rate (54.73%) | 547 | 453 |
| Top-quartile rate (about 70%) | about 700 | about 300 |
| Difference | about 153 more donors kept | about 153 fewer lost |

Each of those roughly 153 donors would otherwise need to be replaced by a new donor, and first-time donors are the group least likely to give again. What each kept donor is worth in dollars depends on the file, and our guide to [what one point of retention is worth](https://donorinsights.com/articles/retention-point-value) walks through that calculation.

The measures in this piece are ones an organization can read on its own records. Donor Insights reads your contacts and gifts and shows retention and gifts per donor by cohort, so a new stewardship behavior can be judged by whether the donors who received it came back. The [methodology](https://donorinsights.com/methodology) starts from your own giving records, and the [platform](https://donorinsights.com/platform) keeps those two numbers in view through the year, which is where stewardship either shows up or does not.

## FAQ

**What is donor stewardship?**

Donor stewardship is the work an organization does for a donor between one ask and the next: thanking the donor, reporting what the gift accomplished, and keeping the donor connected to the work. It can be measured through retention and gifts per donor.

**How do you measure donor stewardship?**

Track two numbers by the year each donor joined: retention, the share of last year's donors who give again, and gift frequency, the number of gifts per donor per year. In the Virtuous 2026 report, top-quartile organizations retained nearly 7 in 10 donors and top performers averaged 6.62 gifts per donor per year.

**Do handwritten thank-you notes improve donor retention?**

Not in the evidence available. In a preregistered field experiment published in 2025 (letters mailed in 2023) with 1,132 past donors of a German opera house, handwritten thank-you postcards did not significantly raise giving compared with printed postcards. What the thank-you says appears to matter more than the format.

**What should a stewardship report include?**

A specific account of where the donor's money goes and what it did, sent before the next ask. In Bloomerang's 2026 donor survey, 94% of donors said they are motivated when an organization tells them exactly where their money will go, and 69% preferred email as the channel.

**Is stewardship different for small organizations?**

The behaviors are the same, but the benchmarks differ. The Virtuous figures come from mid-sized and large organizations. The Fundraising Effectiveness Project, whose broader panel of 15,102 organizations is not limited to mid-sized and large ones, put overall 2025 retention at 43.3%. Compare your file with its own past years first.

## Sources
- [Virtuous (2026). 2026 Nonprofit Fundraising Benchmark Report, press release, April 21, 2026. 771 mid-sized and large US nonprofits (data year not stated).](https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/virtuous-releases-2026-nonprofit-fundraising-benchmark-report-median-gift-up-20-as-donors-who-stay-give-more-often-and-more-generously-302748571.html)
- [Bloomerang with The Harris Poll (2026). 2026 Giving Signals Report, press release, May 19, 2026. Survey of 1,000+ US donors and 400 fundraising leaders, March 13-24, 2026.](https://bloomerang.com/news/bloomerang-releases-2026-giving-signals-report)
- [Adena, M., Huck, S., and Neyse, L. (2025). Gratitude in fundraising: do 'thank you in advance' and handwritten thank you notes impact fundraising success? Experimental Economics, 28(4), 900-909. doi:10.1017/eec.2025.10033](https://doi.org/10.1017/eec.2025.10033)
- [Samek, A., and Longfield, C. (2023). Do Thank-You Calls Increase Charitable Giving? Expert Forecasts and Field Experimental Evidence. American Economic Journal: Applied Economics, 15(2), 103-124. doi:10.1257/app.20210068 (background, pre-2025 data)](https://www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/app.20210068)
- [Neon One (2026). These Automated Reminders Reduce Recurring Donor Churn, summarizing the 2026 Recurring Donor Report. Survey of lapsed recurring donors.](https://neonone.com/resources/blog/fundraising-tools-automated-reminders-recurring-donors/)
- [Fundraising Effectiveness Project (2026). Q4 2025 Report. 15,102 organizations, calendar-year 2025 data.](https://publications.fepreports.org/archive/2025-q4/)

## Disclaimer

**Educational purpose.** This article is published for general informational and educational purposes only. It is not investment, financial, funding, donor, tax, legal, accounting, or fundraising advice, and reading it creates no advisory, fiduciary, or client relationship. Consult your own qualified professionals before making decisions.

**Not an offer.** Nothing here is an offer, solicitation, or recommendation to buy, sell, donate to, or fund any organization or security. Pray, Inc. DonorInsights.com is not a registered investment adviser, broker-dealer, law firm, accounting firm, or fundraising counsel, and publishes only impersonal commentary of general and regular circulation.

**Public data, no guarantee.** Analyses of named organizations rely on public sources such as IRS Form 990 filings, an organization's own published materials, and reputable press. These sources are believed reliable but are not audited or independently verified by us. The content may contain errors or omissions and is provided "as is" with no warranties of accuracy, completeness, or currency.

**Opinions and estimates.** Donor-level and financial figures for named organizations are our inferences and opinions, including forward-looking projections that are not guarantees of future results.

**No affiliation.** Named organizations are independent and are not clients, affiliates, sponsors, or endorsers of DonorInsights.com. Third-party names and trademarks belong to their owners and are used only for identification and commentary. Links to third-party sites are not endorsements.

**No reliance.** We accept no liability for any action taken based on this content.

**Corrections.** This analysis reflects public sources available as of publication. If you are an organization discussed here, or any reader, and you believe a figure or statement is inaccurate, email hello@donorinsights.com and we will review it and correct any error promptly.

Your use of this site is governed by our [Terms of Use](https://donorinsights.com/terms).

Source: DonorInsights.com — https://donorinsights.com/articles/donor-stewardship-defined
