Donor Insights

Donor economics

Do Matching Challenges Raise More Money? What the Experiments Found

A match offer usually raises the total a charity receives, but most of the gain is the matcher's own money, and raising the ratio above one-to-one has not helped in the largest field test. This article explains what the experiments measured and how to use a match honestly.

By Donor Insights · Published November 19, 2026 · 10 min read

Enter your email and we will send the PDF, plus the daily stewardship read each morning. You can unsubscribe from any email.

Key takeaways

  • A matching gift is a funder's promise to add money in proportion to each new gift, and in a 2026 meta-analysis of 137 estimates from 26 giving experiments, matches raised the total a charity received more than tax rebates of the same value did (Clochard, Dey, Sasaki and Imai).
  • In the same meta-analysis, the amount donors paid out of their own pockets responded about equally to matches and rebates, so most of the matching advantage came from the matched dollars themselves, not from donors giving more.
  • In Karlan and List's 2007 field experiment with more than 50,000 past donors, a match offer raised donors' own gifts per letter mailed by 19%, not counting the matched money, and the share who gave by 22%, but $2:$1 and $3:$1 matches raised no more than a $1:$1 match.
  • A challenge gift is a lead gift announced in advance toward a stated goal, and the small studies comparing it with matching disagree on which works better, so the honest answer for an organization is to test both on its own donors.
  • A match adds new money only to the extent that donors give more than they would have without it, or the funder would not otherwise have given, so the letter should describe the match exactly as it works.

A matching gift usually does increase the total donations a charity receives, but most of the increase is the matcher's own money, and the rise in what donors themselves give is much smaller than the rise in the total. A matching gift, in this article, is a funder's promise to add a set amount for every dollar other donors give, up to a cap, such as "every gift doubled up to $10,000." The newest summary of the research is a 2026 meta-analysis by Gwen-Jiro Clochard, Shubham Dey, Shusaku Sasaki, and Taisuke Imai at the University of Osaka, which pooled 137 estimates from 26 experimental papers. It found that the total a charity received rose more under a match than under a tax rebate of equal value, while the amount donors paid out of pocket responded about the same to both. The match's advantage, in other words, came mostly from the dollars the matcher added.

What is the difference between a matching gift and a challenge gift?

A matching gift grows with each new donation, while a challenge gift is a fixed amount announced in advance. With a match, a funder adds money in proportion to what donors give, so a $50 gift becomes $100 for the charity under a one-to-one match, until the funder's cap is reached. With a challenge gift, sometimes called a lead gift, a donor gives or commits a large sum up front, and the organization announces it to show that the goal is reachable and has backing. Terms vary across organizations and consultants, so the letter should always say exactly what happens to the reader's gift.

Both are different from employer matching, in which a donor's employer matches the employee's personal gifts under a company policy. Employer matching depends on the donor knowing about and claiming the benefit, and our guide to employer matching gifts covers it. This article is about a match or challenge that an organization offers to all of its donors in an appeal.

Does a matching gift increase donations?

A matching gift increases the total donations a charity receives in most experiments, because the matched dollars are added on top of what donors give. Economists describe a match as lowering the price of giving, which is what it costs a donor to deliver one dollar to the charity. Under a one-to-one match, a donor who gives $50 delivers $100, so the price of giving is 50 cents per dollar. The meta-analysis measured how strongly giving responds to that price, a quantity called price elasticity. Its pooled estimate for total donations, meaning the amount the charity received including any match, was −1.75. Put plainly, when the price of giving fell by 1%, total donations rose by about 1.75% on average across the studies.

−2.44 vs −0.73
price elasticity of total donations under matching versus under tax rebates, across 137 estimates from 26 experimental papers: total giving responded more than three times as strongly to a match — Clochard, Dey, Sasaki and Imai (2026), University of Osaka ISER Discussion Paper 1299, revised July 2026

The split between matches and rebates explains where the money comes from. A rebate, such as a tax deduction, refunds part of a gift to the donor after the fact. A donor who gives $100 and receives a 50% rebate is out $50 and has delivered $100, exactly as under a one-to-one match, so in theory the two lower the price of giving by the same amount. Under matching, the elasticity of total donations was −2.44, against −0.73 under rebates. But when the authors looked at checkbook donations, the amount donors paid out of their own pockets before any match or refund, they found no statistically significant difference between the two schemes. The authors conclude that matching produces the larger total largely because the charity receives the matcher's money as well as the donor's. The gap narrowed in field experiments compared with laboratory ones, though it did not disappear.

Does a two-to-one or three-to-one match raise more than one-to-one?

No: in the largest field test of match ratios, a two-to-one or three-to-one match raised no more than a one-to-one match. Dean Karlan and John List mailed fundraising letters to more than 50,000 past donors of a U.S. nonprofit and randomly varied the offer, as reported in the American Economic Review (2007). Letters that offered any match raised 19% more in donors' own gifts per letter mailed than letters with no match, a figure that leaves out the matched money, and the share of recipients who gave rose by 22%, both measured relative to the no-match letters. But the size of the match made no difference beyond that. This is older background research, conducted before 2007, and it remains the largest randomized test of match ratios available. The arithmetic shows how the total and donors' own gifts diverge. If donors give 19% more under a one-to-one match and the cap is not reached, the charity receives 2.38 times what donors would have given with no match offer: 1.19 from donors and 1.19 from the matcher. Of that increase, about 86% is the matcher's money and about 14% is new giving from donors (our arithmetic, not a finding of the study).

“Larger match ratios (i.e., $3:$1 and $2:$1) relative to a smaller match ratio ($1:$1) had no additional impact, however.”
Dean Karlan and John A. List, abstract, American Economic Review (2007)

The practical consequence is about the funder's money. A three-to-one match spends three times as much of the matcher's budget per donor dollar as a one-to-one match, so if the larger ratio does not bring in more donors or larger gifts, a one-to-one match lets the same funder cover three times as many gifts before reaching the cap. The table shows the arithmetic.

What each match ratio does to the price of giving and to a $30,000 matching fund (arithmetic, not a study result)
Match offerCharity receives per $1 a donor givesPrice of giving per $1 deliveredDonor dollars a $30,000 fund can match
No match$1$1.00None
$1 added per $1 given (one-to-one)$2$0.50$30,000
$2 added per $1 given (two-to-one)$3$0.33$15,000
$3 added per $1 given (three-to-one)$4$0.25$10,000

Do challenge gifts work better than matching gifts?

The studies that compare challenge gifts and matching gifts directly are small and disagree, so neither form has been shown to win in general. In a field campaign run in June 2004 with the British Columbia chapter of the Sierra Club of Canada, Daniel Rondeau and John List sent letters to 3,000 supporters split into four groups. When the letter announced that a donor had already given $2,500 toward a $5,000 goal, supporters gave $1,620 in total, against $945 when the same $2,500 had been secured but was not mentioned, a 71% difference. The average gift rose from $27.79 to $43.78, and that difference was statistically significant. A one-to-one match in the same campaign did not produce a statistically significant increase. The study appeared in Experimental Economics, and each group had only 30 to 37 donors, so the totals can swing on a few gifts.

A fundraising agency's own test points the other way. Masterworks reports that across three Easter direct mail appeals for one client, matching-gift letters raised gross revenue per thousand letters mailed by 20% against a control group with no offer, while challenge-gift letters showed no significant difference. That is a practitioner case without a published sample size or review, so hold it loosely. Taken together, the two results say the form that works depends on the organization and its donors, which is a reason to test rather than assume.

How much new money does a matching challenge actually bring in?

A matching challenge brings in new money only to the extent that donors give more than they would have without it, plus any part of the matcher's gift that would not have come otherwise. The total raised during a match is not the right measure, because it counts the matcher's dollars as if the match created them. Here is the arithmetic for a fictional organization, Ridgeway Animal Rescue, with made-up figures chosen to show the shape of the question.

Illustrative December appeal for a fictional organization, with and without a $10,000 one-to-one match (hypothetical figures)
MeasureWithout a matchWith a match
Donor gifts$40,000$42,000
Matched dollars from a board memberNone$10,000
Total the charity receives$40,000$52,000
New money if the board member would have given $10,000 anywayNone$2,000
New money if the $10,000 exists only because of the matchNone$12,000

The headline says the match raised $52,000. The honest answer is between $2,000 and $12,000, depending on whether the board member's $10,000 would have arrived in some form without the match. That question is worth asking the matcher directly. A funder who would give the money regardless might be better used as a challenge gift announced up front, while a funder whose gift depends on donors responding is a true match.

How should you write a matching challenge into an appeal?

Write the match into an appeal as one sentence that states who is matching, at what ratio, up to what amount, and by what date, and say what happens if the cap is not reached. The steps below are practitioner guidance built on the research above:

  1. 1.Use a one-to-one match. In the largest ratio test, larger ratios raised no more, and a one-to-one match stretches the funder's money furthest.
  2. 2.Name the matcher if they agree, or describe them truthfully, such as "a member of our board" or "a longtime donor family."
  3. 3.State the cap and the deadline in the same sentence: "Every gift made by December 31 will be matched, up to $10,000."
  4. 4.Say what happens to unmatched money. If the funder gives the full amount regardless, describe it as a challenge gift instead: "A board member has given $10,000 and challenged us to raise $10,000 more."
  5. 5.Report the result afterward. Tell donors whether the match was met and what the combined money paid for, in the next message that is not an ask.

How can you test whether a match works for your donors?

Test a match by randomly splitting one appeal so that half the list sees the match and half sees the same letter without it, then compare donor gifts, not totals, between the two halves. The comparison should leave out the matched dollars, because the question is whether the offer changed what donors gave. Count three things for each half: the share of recipients who gave, the average gift among those who gave, and donor revenue per letter or email sent. A file of a few thousand donors can detect only a large difference in one appeal, so repeat the split across two or three appeals before deciding.

The longer-term question is whether matched donors stay. A donor recruited during a match may expect one the next time. Donor Insights reads your own gift file, so the donors first acquired in a matched appeal can be followed into the next year and compared with donors acquired without one, which shows whether the match brought in donors who renew or donors who gave once. Our guides to ask-amount anchoring and the psychology of fundraising cover the other parts of the ask that experiments have tested.

Frequently asked questions

Is it honest to promote a match if the funder would give the money anyway?
Only if the wording is literally true. If the funder has committed the full amount whatever donors do, describe it as a challenge gift, for example: a board member has given $10,000 and challenged us to raise $10,000 more. Reserve the word match for money that depends on what donors give.
What happens if a matching challenge is not fully met?
That depends on the agreement with the funder, and the appeal should say. Some funders give only the matched portion, and others give the full amount regardless. Ask the funder before the appeal goes out, and tell donors afterward whether the match was met.
Should a small organization use a matching challenge?
It can, if a funder is willing and the terms can be stated truthfully in one sentence. A small match, such as $2,500 from a board member, uses the same wording as a large one. Because small files make results noisy, judge it over two or three appeals rather than one.
Can several donors pool their gifts into one match?
Yes. A matching fund can come from a group of board members or major donors, as long as the appeal describes it accurately, for example: a group of our board members will match every gift up to $15,000.
How long should a matching challenge run?
Long enough for donors to respond through the channels you use, and no longer than the deadline you can state truthfully. Many organizations tie a match to a date that already matters, such as GivingTuesday or December 31, so the match and the deadline reinforce each other.

Sources

  1. Clochard, G.-J., Dey, S., Sasaki, S., and Imai, T. (2026). Revisiting the Price Elasticity of Charitable Giving: Meta-Analysis of Tax Incentives and Matching Donations. ISER Discussion Paper 1299, University of Osaka, December 2025, revised July 2026.
  2. Karlan, D., and List, J. A. (2007). Does Price Matter in Charitable Giving? Evidence from a Large-Scale Natural Field Experiment. American Economic Review 97(5), 1774-1793. Background research.
  3. Rondeau, D., and List, J. A. (2008). Matching and challenge gifts to charity: evidence from laboratory and natural field experiments. Experimental Economics 11(3), 253-267. Field campaign run June 2004. Background research.
  4. Rondeau and List, NBER Working Paper 13728 (2008), Table 1 (totals and average gifts by treatment).
  5. Masterworks. Effectiveness of Matching Gifts vs. Challenge Gifts in Fundraising Campaigns (agency case, sample size not published).

Disclaimer

Educational purpose. This article is published for general informational and educational purposes only. It is not investment, financial, funding, donor, tax, legal, accounting, or fundraising advice, and reading it creates no advisory, fiduciary, or client relationship. Consult your own qualified professionals before making decisions.

Not an offer. Nothing here is an offer, solicitation, or recommendation to buy, sell, donate to, or fund any organization or security. Pray, Inc. DonorInsights.com is not a registered investment adviser, broker-dealer, law firm, accounting firm, or fundraising counsel, and publishes only impersonal commentary of general and regular circulation.

Public data, no guarantee. Analyses of named organizations rely on public sources such as IRS Form 990 filings, an organization's own published materials, and reputable press. These sources are believed reliable but are not audited or independently verified by us. The content may contain errors or omissions and is provided "as is" with no warranties of accuracy, completeness, or currency.

Opinions and estimates. Donor-level and financial figures for named organizations are our inferences and opinions, including forward-looking projections that are not guarantees of future results.

No affiliation. Named organizations are independent and are not clients, affiliates, sponsors, or endorsers of DonorInsights.com. Third-party names and trademarks belong to their owners and are used only for identification and commentary. Links to third-party sites are not endorsements.

No reliance. We accept no liability for any action taken based on this content.

Corrections. This analysis reflects public sources available as of publication. If you are an organization discussed here, or any reader, and you believe a figure or statement is inaccurate, email hello@donorinsights.com and we will review it and correct any error promptly.

Your use of this site is governed by our Terms of Use.