Donor Insights

Recurring giving

Monthly Giving's Second Year: Why Sustainers Leave and What Keeps Them

The most common reason lapsed monthly donors give in surveys is money. A pause or a lower amount, offered before cancellation, is the response worth testing.

By Donor Insights · Published November 11, 2026 · Updated September 25, 2026 · 7 min read

Enter your email and we will send the PDF, plus the daily stewardship read each morning. You can unsubscribe from any email.

Key takeaways

  • M+R Benchmarks 2026 found that 71% of new monthly donors were still giving after a full year and a little more than half were still giving after two full years (2025 data).
  • Of 100 new monthly donors, that means roughly 71 remain at the first anniversary and a little more than 50 at the second, so year two loses roughly another 15 to 20 of the original 100.
  • In Neon One's 2026 survey of lapsed recurring donors, 44.1% said they stopped because they could no longer afford to give, and 27% said they no longer felt connected to the organization's work.
  • At $30 a month, a donor who pauses for three months and resumes gives $270 over the next year, against $0 from a donor who cancels.
  • Whether a pause offer keeps donors has not been measured in the sources cited here, so it is a hypothesis each organization should test on its own file.

Monthly giving keeps losing donors after the first year. M+R Benchmarks 2026, which tracks online monthly giving programs month by month from sign-up, found that 71% of new sustainers, meaning monthly donors, were still giving after a full year, and a little more than half were still giving after two full years. The most common reason recurring donors give in a survey for stopping is money: in Neon One's 2026 Recurring Donor Report, 44.1% of lapsed recurring donors said they could no longer afford it. If affordability is the leading reason, then offering a pause or a smaller amount before a donor cancels should keep some of them, and that is worth testing.

How many monthly giving donors leave in the second year?

M+R's figures describe a curve rather than a single rate. Of new monthly donors, 10% stopped within two months of setting up the gift, 81% were still giving at seven months, 71% at twelve months, and a little more than half after two full years. M+R also notes that after the first year, organizations can expect to lose one or two percent of sustainers each month. Read as a group of 100 new donors, roughly 71 are left at the first anniversary and a little more than 50 at the second. Year two therefore loses roughly another 15 to 20 of the original 100, fewer than year one but still a large share of the donors who made it past their first year.

71%
of new monthly donors still giving after a full year, falling to a little more than half after two full years (M+R Benchmarks 2026, 2025 data) — M+R Benchmarks 2026, Fundraising

Keeping existing sustainers matters more in a year when new monthly revenue is growing slowly. M+R found that online revenue from one-time gifts grew 17% in 2025, faster than the 12% growth in monthly revenue. Recurring gifts still made up nearly 21% of total revenue across the 771 mid-sized and large nonprofits in the Virtuous 2026 benchmark report. Our guide to the sustainer retention curve covers the first months. This piece covers the second year, when a donor has already proven the gift fits their budget once.

Why do monthly donors say they stop giving?

Neon One surveyed recurring donors who had stopped giving. The most common reason, given by 44.1%, was that they could no longer afford it. The second, given by 27%, was that they no longer felt connected to the organization's work or mission. A third group never chose to stop at all: a card expired or a payment failed, and nobody followed up. Neon One's own summary goes further. "The most common reason recurring donors lapse isn't disengagement," it says. "[I]t's a failed payment that nobody caught in time." The 44.1% is the top reason among donors who answered the survey, not a count of every lapse. Our guide to voluntary and involuntary churn covers that third group, and failed payment recovery covers the fix.

Why recurring donors stopped, and the response each reason calls for (reasons from Neon One's 2026 survey of lapsed recurring donors)
ReasonShare of lapsed donorsResponse to test
Could no longer afford it44.1%Offer a pause or a lower amount before the donor cancels
No longer felt connected to the work27%Send a specific report on what monthly gifts did, with no ask
Card expired or payment failedNot quantified in the summarySend card-update reminders and follow up on failed charges

The affordability answer comes from a survey, so it records what donors said rather than what caused them to leave, and some donors may give the polite reason. It is still the reason an organization can plan around, because a pause or a smaller amount changes the choice a donor under financial strain faces.

What is a pause worth compared with a cancellation?

The arithmetic for one donor is simple. Take a donor giving $30 a month, the median first recurring gift in Neon One's transaction data. The table shows what the organization receives over the next 12 months under three outcomes. These are illustrative calculations, not measured results.

Illustrative: 12-month revenue from one $30-a-month donor under three outcomes (arithmetic only)
OutcomeMonths of givingRevenue over 12 months
Donor cancels0$0
Donor pauses for 3 months, then resumes at $309$270
Donor lowers the gift to $15 and keeps giving12$180
Donor keeps giving $3012$360

Picture a fictional organization, Harbor Street Literacy Project, with 200 monthly donors entering their second year. If M+R's curve held on that file, roughly 45 to 55 of them would stop during year two. If 44.1% of those leavers stopped for affordability, as in Neon One's survey, that is roughly 20 to 24 donors. Every one of them who paused for three months instead of cancelling would be worth $270 in the following year. How many would accept a pause is the unknown, and it is the number the test should measure.

How can an organization test a pause offer in monthly giving?

  1. 1.Put the pause option in writing before anyone asks: on the sign-up confirmation, on the donor's account page, and in a line in each quarterly update.
  2. 2.When a donor asks to cancel, offer two choices first: pause for up to three months, or lower the monthly amount. Accept the cancellation immediately if the donor declines both.
  3. 3.Tag every pause and every downgrade in the database, with the date and the reason the donor gave.
  4. 4.At the end of each pause, send a short note before the gift restarts, so the first charge after the pause is expected.
  5. 5.After 12 months, compare second-year retention and revenue for the year the pause was offered against the year before.
  6. 6.For donors who stopped because they felt disconnected, send one specific report on what monthly gifts did before the anniversary of their first gift.

If the pause option also appears in the original ask, as in our monthly giving ask script, the donor learns about it before they ever need it.

The published curve belongs to other organizations, and your file has its own. Donor Insights reads your contacts and gifts and shows the retention curve for your monthly donors by the month they joined, so a pause test can be judged on your own second-year numbers. The methodology starts from your own giving records, and the platform keeps the paused and downgraded donors visible so they are counted as kept, not lost.

Frequently asked questions

What percentage of monthly donors stay after two years?
In M+R Benchmarks 2026, which follows online monthly donors from sign-up, 71% were still giving after a full year and a little more than half after two full years. Organizations with many long-tenured monthly donors will see higher year-over-year retention, which is why Neon One's data shows 78% to 80%.
Why do monthly donors cancel?
In Neon One's 2026 survey of lapsed recurring donors, the most common reason was that they could no longer afford it, at 44.1%. Another 27% said they no longer felt connected to the organization's work. Others stopped because a card expired or a payment failed.
Should a monthly giving program offer a pause?
It is worth testing. Because affordability is the most common stated reason for stopping, a pause or lower amount gives a donor under strain a choice other than cancelling. No source cited here has measured the effect, so compare second-year retention before and after you add the option.
How do you win back a lapsed recurring donor?
Start with the reason. If a card failed, ask the donor to update the payment details. If the donor could not afford it, offer to restart at a lower amount when their situation allows. If the donor felt disconnected, send a specific report on what the gifts did before asking again.
Is monthly giving still growing?
Yes, but more slowly than one-time giving in 2025. M+R found online monthly revenue grew 12% against 17% for one-time gifts, which makes keeping existing monthly donors more important.

Sources

  1. M+R (2026). M+R Benchmarks 2026, Fundraising section (sustainer retention by month, revenue growth). 2025 data.
  2. Neon One (2026). These Automated Reminders Reduce Recurring Donor Churn (lapse reasons from the 2026 Recurring Donor Report survey, which also names failed payments as the most common cause of lapse).
  3. Virtuous (2026). 2026 Nonprofit Fundraising Benchmark Report, press release, April 21, 2026. 771 mid-sized and large US nonprofits (recurring share of revenue).
  4. Neon One (2026). Here's Why Recurring Donors Are the Future: Key Findings from the 2026 Recurring Donor Report. Transactions from 4,107 nonprofits, 2023-2025, and a survey of 718 recurring donors.

Disclaimer

Educational purpose. This article is published for general informational and educational purposes only. It is not investment, financial, funding, donor, tax, legal, accounting, or fundraising advice, and reading it creates no advisory, fiduciary, or client relationship. Consult your own qualified professionals before making decisions.

Not an offer. Nothing here is an offer, solicitation, or recommendation to buy, sell, donate to, or fund any organization or security. Pray, Inc. DonorInsights.com is not a registered investment adviser, broker-dealer, law firm, accounting firm, or fundraising counsel, and publishes only impersonal commentary of general and regular circulation.

Public data, no guarantee. Analyses of named organizations rely on public sources such as IRS Form 990 filings, an organization's own published materials, and reputable press. These sources are believed reliable but are not audited or independently verified by us. The content may contain errors or omissions and is provided "as is" with no warranties of accuracy, completeness, or currency.

Opinions and estimates. Donor-level and financial figures for named organizations are our inferences and opinions, including forward-looking projections that are not guarantees of future results.

No affiliation. Named organizations are independent and are not clients, affiliates, sponsors, or endorsers of DonorInsights.com. Third-party names and trademarks belong to their owners and are used only for identification and commentary. Links to third-party sites are not endorsements.

No reliance. We accept no liability for any action taken based on this content.

Corrections. This analysis reflects public sources available as of publication. If you are an organization discussed here, or any reader, and you believe a figure or statement is inaccurate, email hello@donorinsights.com and we will review it and correct any error promptly.

Your use of this site is governed by our Terms of Use.