Recurring giving
A Monthly Giving Program Script for Faith-Based Nonprofits
A monthly ask for email, phone, and reply card, written for faith-based nonprofits, with the research reason behind every line.
By Donor Insights · Published November 9, 2026 · Updated September 25, 2026 · 8 min read
Enter your email and we will send the PDF, plus the daily stewardship read each morning. You can unsubscribe from any email.
Key takeaways
- In Neon One's 2026 survey of 718 recurring donors, 58.6% said they started their recurring gift without being asked, and only 25% said they started because an organization asked them.
- In Givelify's 2026 Giving in Faith report, run with the Lake Institute and surveying 1,987 Christian donors, 95% said they want to give at least monthly, but only about 30% give that consistently.
- The median first recurring gift in Neon One's transaction data from 4,107 nonprofits was $30, which makes $30 a month a realistic starting amount to name in the ask.
- Among lapsed recurring donors in Neon One's survey, 44.1% said they stopped because they could no longer afford it, so the script offers a pause or a lower amount before a donor cancels.
- M+R Benchmarks 2026 found that 10% of new monthly donors stop within two months, so the script includes a thank-you and a first report inside the first month.
Most recurring donors started on their own. In Neon One's 2026 Recurring Donor Report, which surveyed 718 recurring donors, 58.6% said they started their recurring gift without being asked, and only 25% said they began because an organization asked them. A monthly giving program, meaning a standing invitation for donors to give a set amount every month, depends on the organization actually sending that invitation to donors who would not find it on their own. This article gives faith-based nonprofits a word-for-word monthly ask for email, phone, and the reply card, with the reason behind each line.
Why does a monthly giving program need a written script?
The finding that most recurring donors started without being asked cuts two ways. It shows that people are willing to give monthly with no prompting at all, and it suggests that many organizations are not making the request. A written script fixes the second part. When the words are drafted once, every staff member and volunteer makes the same clear request, and the organization can test one version of the ask against another.
Monthly donors are also worth the effort. In the same Neon One data, which covers transactions at 4,107 nonprofits between 2023 and 2025, recurring donors were retained at 79.11% year over year, against 32.41% for one-time donors. Retention here means the share of donors who give again the following year. Our guide to the monthly upgrade ask works through what that difference is worth in dollars. This piece supplies the words.
What do faith-based donors already believe about regular giving?
Many already hold consistent giving as a goal. In the Givelify and Lake Institute on Faith & Giving 2026 Giving in Faith study, which surveyed 1,987 Christian faith-based donors and 894 church leaders in early 2026, 95% of donors said they want to give at least monthly. Only about 30% maintain that consistent pattern, with consistent giving defined as giving one or more times a month. Church leaders in the study estimated that about 53% of their congregants give consistently, far more than the 30% the study measured.
The study's donors were all Christian, the study centers on church giving, and Givelify sells giving software, so treat the numbers as describing one part of the faith-based audience rather than all of it. The gap between aspiration and practice is still the useful part for a script. A donor who already wants to give regularly does not need to be persuaded that regular giving is good. The ask can present a monthly gift as a way to do what the donor already intends, which is a smaller request than asking for a new commitment.
What does the monthly giving email say, line by line?
The example below is written for a fictional organization, Riverside Family Shelter, a faith-based nonprofit that houses families. Every line is illustrative. Replace the program details with your own, and keep the structure.
- 1.Subject line: "A way to give the way you already intend to." The line speaks to the aspiration most faith-based donors in the Givelify study already hold.
- 2.Opening: "Many of our supporters tell us they want to give regularly, not only when an appeal arrives. A monthly gift makes that simple." The opening names consistency as the donor's own goal before it names the organization's need.
- 3.The ask: "Would you join our monthly partners at $30 a month?" The amount is specific. $30 was the median first recurring gift in Neon One's data, so it matches what many new monthly donors actually choose.
- 4.The result: "$30 a month covers two nights of safe housing for a family." The line tells the donor exactly where the money goes. In Bloomerang's 2026 survey of more than 1,000 US donors, 94% said that kind of specific information motivates them to give. Use a cost your own program can document.
- 5.The reassurance: "You can pause, lower, or change your gift at any time with one reply." The line answers the reason lapsed donors most often gave in Neon One's survey, which is money.
- 6.The close: "Thank you for considering it, and thank you for everything you have already given." The close thanks the donor for past gifts, so the email reads as an invitation rather than a demand.
Why should a monthly ask mention a pause?
Among lapsed recurring donors in Neon One's survey, 44.1% said they stopped because they could no longer afford to give, the most common reason given. Another 27% said they no longer felt connected to the organization's work. A donor who loses a job or faces a large bill has two choices if the organization offers only one path: keep paying or cancel. Offering a pause or a smaller amount gives a third choice.
No study cited here measures how many donors a pause option keeps, so treat it as a reasonable hypothesis to test on your own file rather than a proven effect. The reasoning is direct: if affordability is the leading reason donors leave, an option that lowers the cost of staying should keep some of them. Mentioning the pause at the start also tells the donor the commitment is not a trap, which may make the first yes easier.
What does the phone ask and the reply card say?
On the phone, the same beats take about a minute. Call donors who have given at least twice this year, because they have already shown a regular pattern.
- "Thank you for your gifts this year. I wanted to tell you what they did." Share one specific result.
- "A lot of our supporters have told us they would like to give regularly. Would you consider a monthly gift of $30?"
- If the donor hesitates: "Any amount works, and you can pause it any time." Then stop talking and let the donor answer.
- If the donor says no: "That is completely fine. Thank you for what you already do." Record the answer and do not ask again for several months.
| Reply card line | Why it is there |
|---|---|
| Yes, I will give monthly: $15 / $30 / $50 / other | Names $30, the median first recurring gift in Neon One's data, with a lower and higher option. |
| Each $30 provides two nights of housing for a family | Tells the donor where the money goes (94% motivated, Bloomerang 2026 survey). |
| Pause or change any time by replying to any email | Answers affordability, the top lapse reason at 44.1% (Neon One survey). |
| I prefer to keep giving one gift at a time | Lets a donor decline without discarding the card or the relationship. |
What happens after the donor says yes?
The first weeks decide whether the new monthly gift lasts. M+R Benchmarks 2026 found that 10% of new monthly donors stopped giving within two months of setting up their gift, and 71% were still active after a full year. A new monthly donor should hear from the organization before the second charge arrives.
- 1.Within two days, send a thank-you that names the amount and the date of the first charge.
- 2.Within the first month, send one specific report on what monthly gifts did, with no ask attached.
- 3.Before any card expires, send a short update request, since an expired card ends a gift the donor never chose to stop. Our guide to failed payment recovery covers the details.
- 4.Every quarter, repeat the pause option in plain words, so a donor under financial strain lowers the gift instead of cancelling it.
The script is a starting point, and your own donors are the test. Donor Insights reads your contacts and gifts, so you can see how many donors accepted the monthly ask, what amount they chose, and how many are still giving six months later. The methodology starts from your own giving records, and the platform tracks the sustainer retention curve for the donors your new script brought in.
Frequently asked questions
- What is a monthly giving program?
- A monthly giving program is a standing invitation for donors to give a set amount every month, usually charged automatically to a card or bank account. Donors in these programs are often called sustainers or monthly partners.
- How much should a monthly giving ask suggest?
- Name a specific amount near what new monthly donors actually choose. In Neon One's transaction data from 4,107 nonprofits, the median first recurring gift was $30. Offer a lower and a higher option beside it, and an open field.
- Should faith-based nonprofits frame monthly giving differently?
- The framing can start from what donors already want. In Givelify's 2026 Giving in Faith report, run with the Lake Institute, 95% of Christian faith-based donors said they want to give at least monthly, but only about 30% give that consistently. A monthly gift can be presented as a way to do what the donor already intends.
- Should the ask mention that donors can pause?
- Yes. Among lapsed recurring donors in Neon One's survey, 44.1% said they stopped because they could no longer afford it. Offering a pause or lower amount gives a donor under strain a choice other than cancelling. Test the effect on your own file.
- Who should receive the monthly ask first?
- Start with donors who have given at least twice this year, because they already give in a regular pattern. Then include recent first-time donors in the weeks after their thank-you, when the organization is fresh in their mind.
Sources
- Neon One (2026). Here's Why Recurring Donors Are the Future: Key Findings from the 2026 Recurring Donor Report. Transactions from 4,107 nonprofits, 2023-2025, and a survey of 718 recurring donors.
- Neon One (2026). These Automated Reminders Reduce Recurring Donor Churn (lapse reasons from the 2026 Recurring Donor Report survey).
- Givelify Philanthropic Research & Insights and Lake Institute on Faith & Giving (2026). Giving in Faith, press release distributed by RNS Press Release Distribution Service, June 9, 2026. Survey of 1,987 Christian donors and 894 church leaders, early 2026.
- Givelify Philanthropic Research & Insights (2026). The Consistent Giving Model, 2026 Giving in Faith Report (95% want to give at least monthly, about 30% give consistently).
- Bloomerang with The Harris Poll (2026). 2026 Giving Signals Report, press release, May 19, 2026. Survey of 1,000+ US donors, March 13-24, 2026.
- M+R (2026). M+R Benchmarks 2026, Fundraising section. 2025 data.
Related articles
The Monthly Upgrade Ask: How to Invite a One-Time Donor Into Monthly Giving
The gap between a one-time donor and a monthly donor is $3,681. One well-made invitation crosses it.
The Sustainer Retention Curve: Why Monthly Donors Stay
Monthly donors keep giving far longer than one-time donors, yet the early months decide who stays. The curve is where the value is.
Building a Monthly Giving Program That Sticks
Recurring gifts are the steadiest money a nonprofit has. Here is how to build the program that produces them.
Disclaimer
Educational purpose. This article is published for general informational and educational purposes only. It is not investment, financial, funding, donor, tax, legal, accounting, or fundraising advice, and reading it creates no advisory, fiduciary, or client relationship. Consult your own qualified professionals before making decisions.
Not an offer. Nothing here is an offer, solicitation, or recommendation to buy, sell, donate to, or fund any organization or security. Pray, Inc. DonorInsights.com is not a registered investment adviser, broker-dealer, law firm, accounting firm, or fundraising counsel, and publishes only impersonal commentary of general and regular circulation.
Public data, no guarantee. Analyses of named organizations rely on public sources such as IRS Form 990 filings, an organization's own published materials, and reputable press. These sources are believed reliable but are not audited or independently verified by us. The content may contain errors or omissions and is provided "as is" with no warranties of accuracy, completeness, or currency.
Opinions and estimates. Donor-level and financial figures for named organizations are our inferences and opinions, including forward-looking projections that are not guarantees of future results.
No affiliation. Named organizations are independent and are not clients, affiliates, sponsors, or endorsers of DonorInsights.com. Third-party names and trademarks belong to their owners and are used only for identification and commentary. Links to third-party sites are not endorsements.
No reliance. We accept no liability for any action taken based on this content.
Corrections. This analysis reflects public sources available as of publication. If you are an organization discussed here, or any reader, and you believe a figure or statement is inaccurate, email hello@donorinsights.com and we will review it and correct any error promptly.
Your use of this site is governed by our Terms of Use.